Gold & Bitcoin vs. the World
Posted November 17, 2021
Bitcoiners tell you to drop gold. Gold bugs tell you to drop bitcoin.
Grand scheme? They’re both wrong.
It’s not gold vs. bitcoin.
It’s gold and bitcoin vs. the world.
Yes, we’re bulls on bitcoin and crypto. We think crypto solves more problems than gold does, therefore the upside potential is far greater. Gold solves only one problem.
I’ll get to that in a moment.
First, consider this.
The Pimple on the Elephant
As Rick Rule, CEO of Sprott Global Resource Investments, recently pointed out…
The market cap of gold and bitcoin combined amount to about $14 trillion. Whereas the market cap of total savings and investment assets worldwide is $650 trillion.
Thus, to paraphrase Robert Friedland, gold and bitcoin combined have the importance worldwide of a pimple on an elephant’s behind.
Therefore, says Rule, “The real enemy… the real competitor for gold is probably the S&P 500.” Not bitcoin.
Indeed, between gold and bitcoin, he says, “there is a fight for the imagination. But that fight is more fiction than fact.”
Meaning? There’s tons of room for both of them.
Here’s how I think about it…
Precious metals are a fine bet in case I’m wrong.
Crypto is a great bet in case I’m right.
(Of course, I’d rather be right.)
But, as Jeffrey Tucker put it in today’s featured article below…
Perhaps you don’t have to choose.
The Golden Constant Is Back
By Jeffrey Tucker
It used to be a doctrine. When inflation picks up, so does the gold price. Generations have figured this out, and gold has never gone away as the go-to safe haven asset. After 40 years of relatively low inflation, it’s become perhaps unfashionable, but the fundamentals that have made it a safe haven for thousands of years are still with us.
It used to be the case that you would follow the inflation numbers, and adjust one’s portfolio based on the outlook by buying gold and mining stocks. Today, it might be wise to reverse that: follow the gold price and you gain great insight into the future of inflation.
Gold has come alive, reaching $1,800. Central bank purchases, consumer demand, shifts in portfolios by individual account holders all play a role here. The conviction that inflation is bad and getting worse all play a role here. Fiat money has not in our lifetimes had such a bad reputation and prognosis.
At the same time, the best way to understand the rise of an inflation hedge is to view it in real terms, which is to say adjusted for the manner in which the dollar itself has depreciated. Here you get a different picture. In real terms, by today’s dollar, gold of October 1979 was running $489. By the end of the year, in today’s dollars with adjustment, gold reached $1,800. That is where we sit today. In other words, in real terms, and depending on how you calculate inflation today, we are nearing or at a high.
For some people, this development is inevitable. Gold has been called a “constant” for a reason. It is a hedge, not a means of profiting as such but as a protection against the chaos of the world. That’s saying something important. It is a wise move, but not necessarily a means of gaining riches — unless and to the extent that we really face an out-of-control hyperinflation.
For other people, the activity in gold today might be a bit of a surprise. The only serious competitor that gold has had in our times has been the advent of cryptocurrency. It has all the features of gold. It is scarce, indestructible, fungible, and has an even quality across all possible units. Bitcoin and others add two features that make it even more attractive. It is weightless and instantly transferable without the cost of physically moving the stuff from place to place.
There is a downside to crypto. Using it requires access to the Internet under general conditions. If your cell phone dies because the electricity is out, you are out of luck. If the government shuts down the Internet, you are also stuck. All of that is true, but there are several confusions people have here as well.
Myth and Fact
First, it is possible to have physical bitcoin. You can print out your wallet on a piece of paper. You have it and can use it, even if you go years without internet access. Many high-end holders do this and keep it in a safe. That way, there is no way to gain access to it merely by getting access to the online wallet that stores your encrypted key.
Second, even if you lose access for however long (let’s say you get shipwrecked on a deserted island), that does nothing to change your ownership status. If you have your passphrase stored somewhere (or, more implausibly, memorized) you can recreate your access merely by typing that code in at some point: tomorrow, next year, or in a hundred years. Your money is still there.
Third, if you die, even then your ownership is not in question, since none of it exists under your personal identity as such. Your access is controlled by whomever has access to your private key. Therefore, you can store your codes in an email or program somewhere or on paper, and put the instructions on how to get to it in a will or some other method. Whomever gains access to that is now the owner of your holdings.
For this reason, it is not really possible to enforce some legal action against anyone who “steals” your bitcoin. In some sense, it is a free-for-all. Anyone who hacks your wallet, or anyone to whom you send you units whether on purpose or by mistake, is now the owner. This is the “law” of cryptocurrency. This is why it is a huge issue to maintain tight security protocols.
This problem is not unique to crypto. Gold too had this issue. When FDR demanded that everyone turn in his gold in 1933, only a portion of the population complied. The rest —I’m thinking of very wealthy families mostly in the Northeast at the time and some in the West — had to figure out a way to hide it in their backyards or find a trusted third party who would hold it for decades until it became legal again.
There were such options available, but they were kept super secret. Estates around the country in remote locations fashioned themselves as safe houses for gold storage. They kept the secret through the whole of the Great Depression, World War II, and all the way until 1974 when owning gold became legal again. Then their descendants took off to pick up what had been left behind.
In this way, gold and Bitcoin both face a problem of security. It is up to the individuals to solve it.